Shoppers comparing the value end of the catalogue usually end up looking at the same two families: Putters and Rolled Gold. Both are sold as packs and cartons, both sit alongside the cheaper native-style brands, and both are priced per variant rather than per brand — which is exactly where the decision gets made.
This guide compares the two lineups against the live listings: what each family contains, what the cartons cost, what that works out to per cigarette, which one has the menthol, and how a cart built from either brand behaves against the shipping threshold and the spend tiers.
Quick answer: which of the two is cheaper
Putters Full Flavor has the cheapest carton in the pair at $29.00. Every other carton across both families is $38.99, including Putters Light, Rolled Gold Full Flavor, Rolled Gold Light and Rolled Gold Menthol. The pack price is $5.00 on four of the five variations; Rolled Gold Menthol is the exception at $6.00.
Lineup Variant Pack Carton Per stick ------------ ------------ ------ ------- --------- Putters Full Flavor $5.00 $29.00 14.5 cents Putters Light $5.00 $38.99 19.5 cents Rolled Gold Full Flavor $5.00 $38.99 19.5 cents Rolled Gold Light $5.00 $38.99 19.5 cents Rolled Gold Menthol $6.00 $38.99 19.5 cents
The per-stick column is the number to keep in mind. A $29.00 carton of 200 cigarettes is 14.5 cents a cigarette. A $38.99 carton of the same 200 cigarettes is 19.5 cents. The gap is $9.99 per carton, which is five cents on every stick.
The two lineups side by side
Putters is a two-variant family: a full flavour and a light. Rolled Gold is a three-variant family: a full flavour, a light and a menthol. Neither brand carries an ultra light, so if the mildest tier is what you smoke, this comparison will end with you looking at the Classics lineups instead.
- Putters: two variants, one of them in the $29.00 carton band. No menthol, no ultra light.
- Rolled Gold: three variants, including the only menthol. All three cartons sit at $38.99.
- What they share: 20 cigarettes per pack, 10 packs per carton, 200 cigarettes per carton, and both pack and carton available on every variation.
- Where they differ: the pack price on Rolled Gold Menthol, which is $6.00 rather than $5.00.
Putters: two variants, one real decision
Putters Full Flavor
Putters Full Flavor is the value anchor of the comparison. The carton is $29.00 and the pack is $5.00, which puts it in the small group of listings priced under the standard carton rate. The catalogue describes it as the bolder of the two Putters variants, with the fuller body you would expect from a full-flavour blend.
For a full-flavour smoker who does not want to spend $38.99 on a carton, this is the most direct answer in the catalogue. It is the same 200 cigarettes, in the same pack and carton format, at $9.99 less than the standard rate.
Putters Light
Putters Light is the milder of the two, described in the listing as a smoother, gentler draw. The catch is the price: the light sits at the standard $38.99 carton rate, so choosing the lighter variant inside Putters costs $9.99 more per carton than choosing the full flavour. That is a pricing pattern worth knowing before you assume the whole brand is cheap — it is not, only one variant is.
What Putters does not make
There is no Putters menthol and no Putters ultra light. That is the whole lineup: two variants, five dollars a pack, one carton at $29.00 and one at $38.99. If you want a cooler smoke or a lighter-than-light tier inside the same brand, Putters will not get you there and you will need to switch families.
Rolled Gold: three variants and the $6.00 pack
Rolled Gold Full Flavor
Rolled Gold Full Flavor is the full-strength option, described in the catalogue as a traditional native-style full-flavour blend. Pack $5.00, carton $38.99. It is the direct head-to-head competitor to Putters Full Flavor and the $9.99 difference between the two cartons is the single biggest decision in this comparison.
Rolled Gold Light
Rolled Gold Light is the milder blend of the three, listed as a smoother, lower-strength version of the same brand character. Pack $5.00, carton $38.99 — the same price as Putters Light, so between these two lights the choice comes down to which one you prefer in a $5.00 test pack rather than to price.
Rolled Gold Menthol
Rolled Gold Menthol is the odd one out on price. The carton is $38.99 like the rest of the family, but the single pack is $6.00 — the only $6.00 pack in the cigarette catalogue, where everything else is $5.00. If you buy packs rather than cartons, that extra dollar is the practical difference between this brand and a $5.00 pack. If you buy the carton, the pack price stops mattering and you pay the same $38.99 as any other standard carton.
Full flavour head to head: $29.00 against $38.99
This is the comparison most shoppers are actually making. Putters Full Flavor at $29.00 against Rolled Gold Full Flavor at $38.99. Same pack size, same carton count, same 200 cigarettes inside. The $9.99 difference is a listing-level difference, not a claim that one blend is better than the other.
Put the two numbers on a per-stick basis and the gap is easier to see:
- $29.00 carton ÷ 200 cigarettes = 14.5 cents per cigarette
- $38.99 carton ÷ 200 cigarettes = 19.5 cents per cigarette
- One carton a month for a year: $348.00 against $467.88, a difference of $119.88
Whether that difference matters depends on how you buy. If you are choosing one carton to test a brand, the $9.99 is noise. If you are running a carton a month for a year, it is about the price of three more $38.99 cartons. The full price structure across all 46 listings is in the cigarette price list if you want to check the bands against other brands before you commit.
Lights head to head: both at $38.99
Between Putters Light and Rolled Gold Light there is no price decision at all. Both are $5.00 a pack and $38.99 a carton. Both are described as the milder variant of their family. That makes this the one pairing in the article where you should buy two $5.00 packs, smoke them in the order you normally smoke, and let the packs settle it.
Two packs is $10.00 and gives you 40 cigarettes to judge. That is a cheap way to avoid a $38.99 carton you do not want. If you are new to either brand, the first-time buyer guide walks through the same test-before-you-commit logic from a standing start.
Menthol: only one side has it
Putters has no menthol, so if menthol is non-negotiable the comparison is over and Rolled Gold Menthol is the answer from this pair. It is the only menthol in the two lineups, and it is the only $6.00 pack on the shelf.
It is not the only menthol in the catalogue, though. If you want to compare the cooler options before choosing, the other menthol listings are Classics Menthol, Canadian Menthol, BB Menthol, Canadian Classics Menthol, Playfare Menthol and the Canadian Blend menthol from Discount. All except Rolled Gold are $5.00 a pack and $38.99 a carton. The menthol buying guide covers the full set in one place, and the switching off menthol guide guide is the one to read if you are moving in the other direction, off menthol and back to a regular blend.
Pack first, carton second: the $5.00 test
Both families sell single packs, and the arithmetic makes the pack a sensible first purchase even when you intend to buy cartons long term. A $29.00 carton is the same money as 5.8 packs. A $38.99 carton is the same money as 7.8 packs. Five packs is 100 cigarettes — half a carton — for $25.00, which is enough to know whether the blend suits you.
The other reason to start with packs is that the pack price is identical across both brands at $5.00, apart from the menthol. Testing four packs — Putters Full Flavor, Putters Light, Rolled Gold Full Flavor and Rolled Gold Light — costs $20.00 and covers the entire decision space of this comparison. The pack sizes guide post explains what a pack and a carton actually contain if you want the format detail before ordering.
Cart planning against shipping and the spend tiers
Shipping inside Canada is a flat $15.00 or $20.00 depending on the option you pick at checkout, with free shipping once the cart passes $99.00. On top of that, three cart-total tiers add free merchandise: a free pack at $80.00, a free carton at $240.00 and two free cartons at $480.00. Every one of those thresholds is measured on the cart, not on the shipment, so a cart built from either brand behaves the same way.
What that looks like with Putters Full Flavor at $29.00 a carton:
Cart Total Shipping ----------------------------------------- ------- -------- 2 cartons Putters Full Flavor $58.00 $15.00 3 cartons Putters Full Flavor $87.00 $15.00 4 cartons Putters Full Flavor $116.00 free 8 cartons + 2 packs (clears the $240 tier) $242.00 free 16 cartons + 2 packs + 1 menthol pack $480.00 free
Two things stand out. First, three cartons at $87.00 still pay shipping, because the free-shipping line is $99.00 — the fourth carton is the one that crosses it. Second, $29.00 cartons make the top spend tier unusually reachable: sixteen cartons plus a couple of $5.00 packs and one $6.00 menthol pack lands exactly on $480.00, which is the two-free-cartons tier. The bundle deals guide post and the free shipping guide post cover the threshold logic in more detail, and $50, $100 and $200 cart walkthrough works the same numbers at $50, $100 and $200.
If you are deliberately building a cart around either brand, the free pack at $80, free carton at $240 and two free cartons at $480 listings are the free-item products that arrive with the tiers, and the mystery cigarette pack and mystery cigarette carton are the other two non-standard listings worth knowing about when you are one item short of a threshold.
Where the pair sits against the rest of the value tier
Putters Full Flavor is one of exactly five cartons in the $29.00 band. The other four are Discount Full Flavor, Discount Lights, Playfare Ultra Light and Time Blue. Everything else in the cigarette catalogue is $38.99, which means the value decision is usually not “which brand is cheap” but “does the variant I want happen to sit in the lower band”.
Rolled Gold sits entirely in the standard band, so it competes on lineup width instead: three variants in one brand, including a menthol. The Classics, Canadian, BB, Playfare, Canadian Classics, Time, Nexus, Discount, DK’s, dM, Canadian Premium and Canadian Goose families all sit at the same $38.99 rate per variant, so price rarely separates them — the variant ladder does.
If you want the two families compared in the same format as this article, the Discount vs Playfare comparison and BB vs Canadian Classics comparison posts use the same structure. The catalogue strength map lays out every brand against its strength tiers, and cheap versus premium comparison explains how the bands were drawn.
If neither brand has the variant you want
Two gaps are worth naming. Neither Putters nor Rolled Gold makes an ultra light, and Putters makes no menthol.
- Ultra light: Classics Extra Lights, Canadian Ultra Lights, Canadian Classics Ultra Blue and Playfare Ultra Light are the four lightest listings, and the Playfare one is in the $29.00 band.
- Full flavour outside the pair: Canadian Full, Canadian Classics Original, BB Full Flavor, Classics Full Flavor, Nexus Full Flavor, DK’s Full, Canadian Premium Original and Canadian Goose all sit at $38.99.
- Light outside the pair: Canadian Lights, Canadian Classics Silver, BB Light, Classics Lights, Nexus Light, DK’s Light and Canadian Premium Special.
- Menthol outside the pair: Classics Menthol, Canadian Menthol, BB Menthol, Canadian Classics Menthol and Playfare Menthol.
One formatting note if you are comparing cartons: nearly every carton here is ten packs of twenty, but the Canadian Goose listing is described as eight packs of twenty-five. Both come to 200 cigarettes, so the per-stick maths above still holds — just do not count packs when you are comparing.
Keeping a carton in shape between orders
If you buy four cartons to clear the shipping threshold, three of them will be sitting in a cupboard for months. Keep the cartons closed until you need them, keep them out of a hot car or a bathroom, and keep packs out of a coat pocket that collects lint. The storing cigarettes guide covers the detail, and taste fatigue guide is worth a read if the same brand starts tasting flat after a few months of it.
Paying for the order and receiving it
Two card listings, Interac e-Transfer and cryptocurrency are the payment options at checkout. Card and crypto clear at the time you pay; an e-Transfer order sits on hold until the transfer is confirmed. Cash on delivery is not offered. Orders placed before the daily cut-off move into the same-day dispatch queue, and a signature with photo ID is required at the door on qualifying orders, which is covered in receiving an order guide and payment methods guide.
A five-minute ordering checklist
- Decide the variant first, then the brand: the carton price follows the variant, not the label on the family.
- If you want the $29.00 carton, it has to be Putters Full Flavor — the other Putters variant is $38.99.
- If you want a menthol in this pair, it is Rolled Gold Menthol, and the pack is $6.00 while the carton stays $38.99.
- Buy single packs to test; four packs covers both families for $20.00.
- Check the cart total against $99.00 for free shipping and $80.00, $240.00 or $480.00 for the free-item tiers.
- Confirm the variant name on the cart line before paying — two variants of the same brand can differ by $9.99.
Frequently asked questions
Is Putters cheaper than Rolled Gold?
Only in full flavour. Putters Full Flavor is $29.00 a carton against $38.99 for Rolled Gold Full Flavor. Putters Light and Rolled Gold Light are both $38.99, so the two brands cost the same at the light tier.
Does Putters make menthol cigarettes?
No. The Putters lineup is two variants, full flavour and light. The menthol in this comparison comes from Rolled Gold.
Does Rolled Gold make ultra light cigarettes?
No. Rolled Gold stops at a light. The ultra light tier is covered by Classics Extra Lights, Canadian Ultra Lights, Canadian Classics Ultra Blue and Playfare Ultra Light.
Why is the Rolled Gold Menthol pack $6.00 when the others are $5.00?
The listing prices it that way. The carton is the same $38.99 as the other standard cartons, so the difference only shows up if you are buying single packs.
Is a $29.00 carton smaller than a $38.99 carton?
No. Both are ten packs of twenty, 200 cigarettes. The price difference is $9.99 and the cigarette count is identical.
Can I order both brands in the same cart?
Yes. Mixing families and formats in one cart is normal, and both count toward the same shipping and spend thresholds. A common build is three $29.00 cartons plus a $5.00 pack to cross $99.00 and pick up the free pack at $80.00 on the way.
Do these prices change?
They can. The numbers in this article match the live listings on the date it was published, and the product pages are always the authority — check the carton price on the listing before you build a large order around it.
Where to start
If you want the cheapest carton in this pair, start with Putters Full Flavor. If you want the widest lineup, including the menthol, start with the Rolled Gold brand page and pick a pack. If you would rather browse everything before deciding, the cigarette category category and the shop page page carry the full range, and the first-time buyer guide guide covers the ordering basics.
Both families ship from the same warehouse, under the same $99.00 free-shipping line and the same spend tiers, so the only decision left is which variant you actually want to smoke.
